A plea for sanity

It’s taken a long time but finally Bolsover Council has told the public what it is doing with some of its money at least.

The Council minutes for the 25^th April 2012 have only just become available and state that the overall expenditure requirement for Clowne Campus is £5.884m and the cost of the mini-hub in Bolsover are put at £2.433m making a total of £8.3m if everything goes according to plan. The minutes don’t tell us what they hope to sell Sherwood Lodge to Morrison’s for but with opposition from the public, traders and organisations in the town growing rapidly, they may get a lots less than they think for it. In the meantime they are funding this entire pipe-dream by borrowing money.

 

Can we trust the Council with this mega-deal? Well in all honesty it hasn’t got a good reputation. Last year the External Auditors told the Council that they had “fundamental errors” in reconciling income and expenditure and “Significant governance weakness in contract arrangements”. Even a Council with the very best financial controls would know that in major developments, especially in a Conservation area, can easily have over-runs of 25% or more. On this basis Bolsover DC would need to be getting well over £10M from Sherwood Lodge just to balance the books.

 

The truth is that the whole deal doesn’t stack financially, environmentally, socially or for the economic health of Bolsover. The public of Bolsover want to keep Sherwood Green as a park and the traders of Bolsover certainly don’t want to lose Middle Street car park. Currently Morrison’s haven’t even applied for planning permission for Sherwood Lodge and the prospects of its being granted are rapidly disappearing over the horizon.

 

By failing to consult the pubic properly, the Council has got this badly wrong. It has rushed to the very edge of a financial cliff and is teetering n the brink. There is however still time for them to wake-up smell the coffee and put a stop to the whole calamitous exercise. They can then do what every other Council has done and start the savings exercise by implementing the findings of their own independent panel on member’s remuneration (which would save over £400,000) and then come out of their ivory tower and work with the public to make Bolsover better again.

Tears of a Cowne

I've sent this to the Derbyshire Times:

Tears of a Clowne

Amongst all the hype about the decision by Bolsover Council to purchase Clowne College Campus here’s a few facts:

1.       Morrison’s have not agreed to purchase Sherwood Lodge, nor have they applied for planning permission.

2.       Clowne College was built with public money. Bolsover residents are now being asked to buy-back what they already own.

3.       Bolsover Council is cutting its office use by 40% through new technology and won’t even need all the classroom space at Clowne let alone 12.5 acres of pitches, workshops, sports facilities, canteen and a nursery all of which it will liable for rates.

4.       Clowne Campus was built to a high spec because we need to equip young people with the best skills for them to succeed. Instead of stripping its assets, Bolsover Council should be campaigning to prevent its closure. A supermarket in Bolsover may be convenient but it’s training not shopping that will get our economy out of recession.

5.       Sherwood Lodge is not yet 20 years old, built by the same Labour Councillors who now complain that it is inefficient. But they haven’t told us the costs of the “extras” like providing the IT and telephony services along with reception areas and provision for public meetings in Clowne campus.

It has been suggested to me that having over-inflated their allowances Labour Councillors are adopting the same approach to their office requirements. However if they think that the recession has bottomed out, and now’s the time to speculate, then they must have more faith in the coalition than I do. Elsewhere other Councils don’t indulge in pipe-dreams but work with communities to create jobs by insulating cold Victorian homes, providing solar panels, paying a living wage, supporting local businesses, improving green spaces and keeping essential services, like public toilets, open. Bolsover should take note.